The nature of the motion and how its existence in the material world; A comparative study between Philosophers of Isfahan and Tehran Schools

Author
S. Nazari Tavakkoli
Tehran University
Abstract
Understanding the essence of movement and knowing how it exists in the physical world, is considered one of the most important philosophical issues in which wise men were occupied with, whether in the Greek era or the Islamic one. And if the presence of change was of much certainty as well as movement in the physical world, then, the most important issue is the study of how it is present outwardly. There are, actually four theories about the continuity and the outward disconnection of movement while keeping its unity Mirdamad was the first Muslim philosopher who claimed, contrary to his ancestor, the realization of movement in its two forms in the physical world. While Shirazi defended this theory covertly in his reply against the evidences of those who denied the absolute movement. But Tabatabay changed the direction of studying the issue when he stated that there are two considerations of movement with being of kinds.

Keywords

Subjects

1.Al-Aesam, A. A. (1984). Al-Mostalah Al-Falsafi eind al-Arab. Bagdad.
2.Al-Alavi, H. (1971). Nazariya Al-Harakat Al-Johariya eind Al-Shirazi. Bagdad: al-Irshad publication.
3.Al-Feyz Al-Kashani, M. (1982/1403Ah). Osuol Al-Maaref (2th ed). Edited by Seyyed Jalal al-Din al-Ashtiyani. Qum: Al-Eilam al-Islami.
4.Al-ghazali, M. (2003/1424Ah). Maghsid al-Falasafa. Edited by Soleyman Donya. Tehran: Shams Tabrizi publication. 5.Al-Hilli, H. (1986/1407Ah). Kashf Al-Morad fi Sharh Tjrid Al-Ietegad. Correction by Hasnzade Amoli. Qum: Institute of Nashr al-Islami.
6.Al-Isfahani, Sh. (1905/1323Ah). Matalie Al-Anzar. Cairo: Khayriya publication.
7.Al-Kolayni, M. (2009/1388Sh). Al-Kafi (3th ed). Edited by Ali Akbar al-Ghaffari. Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Islamiya. 8.Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (1987/1408Ah). Kitab Al-Qabasat (2th ed). Edited by Mahdi Mohaghegh. Tehraan: Tehran University.
9. Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (1994/1415Ah). Nibras Al-Ziae. Edited by Hamed Al-Naji. Tehran: Daftar Nashr Mirath al-Maktoob.
10. Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (2002/1381Sh). Al-Imazat (Mosannafat al-Mirdamad, vol.1, p1-211). Edited by abd al-Allah al-Noorani. Tehran: Tehran university.
11. Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (2002/1381Sh). Khalsat Al-Malakuot (Mosannafat al-Mirdamad, vol.1, p281-328). Edited by abd al-Allah al-Noorani. Tehran: Tehran university.
12. Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (2002/1423Ah), Al-Sirat Al-Mostaghim fi rabt Al-Hadith bi Al-Ghadim. Edited by Ali al-Ojabi, Tehran: Daftar Nashr Mirath al-Maktoob.
13. Al-Mirdamad, M. B. (2006/1385Sh). Al-Ofog al-Mobin. Tehran: Tehran university.
14.Al-Razi, F. (1966). Al-Mabahith Al-Mashrigiya. Tehran: Asadi publication.
15.Al-Sabzevari, M. H. (1995/1416Ah). Ghorar Al-Faraeid (Sharh al-Manzooma). Correction by Masood Talebi. Tehran: Nab publication. Downloaded from aijh.modares.ac.ir at 9:06 IRST on Saturday January 11th 2020
16.Al-Shafiei, H. M. (2004/1425Ah). Nazariya Al-Harakat al-Johariya eind Molla Sadra Fi siyag al-Fikr al-Islami. Tehran: Molla Sadra Congress.
17.Al-Shirazi, S. M. (/19821361Sh). Al-Hikmat Al-Arshiya. Correction by Gholam Hosein al-Ahani. Tehran: Mola publication.
18. Al-Shirazi, S. M. )1934/1313 Sh ( Sharh al-Hidaya al-athiriya. Tehran: Dar al-Tibaa li Aga seyyed Mortaza.
19. Al-Shirazi, S. M. (1975/1354Sh), Al-Mabdae Va al-Maad. Correction by Seyyed Jalal al-Din al-Ashtiyani. Tehran: Iranian Philosophical Society.
20. Al-Shirazi, S. M. (1981). Al-Hikmat al-Motaaliya fi Al-Asfar al-Agliya Al-Arbaah. Birut: Dar al-Ehyaa.
21. Al-Shirazi, S. M . ) 1981/1402ـAh). Asrar al-Ayat. Correction by mohammad al-Khajavi. Tehran: Iranian Philosophical Society.
22. Al-Shirazi, S. M . (ـ1983/1404Ah). Kitab Al-Mashaer (2th ed). Tehran: Maktaba Tahouri.
23. Al-Shirazi, S. M. )n.d). Al-Hashiya ala Elahiyat Al- shifa. Qum: Bidar Publication.
24.Al-Shirazi, S. M )1985/1364Sh). Al- Shavahid al-Robubiya. Correction by Seyyed Jalal al-Din al-Ashtiyani. Mashhad: Mashhad University.
25.Al-Sohravardi, Sh. (/20011380Sh). Al-Talvihat Al-Lohiya va Al-Arshiya (3th ed). Correction by Henry Corban. Tehran: Institute for Humanities and Islamic Studies.
26.Al-Tabatabaee, M. H. (1988/1409Ah). Nahayat al-Hikmah. Tehran: Al-Zahra publication.
27.Ashtiany, J. (2001/1380Sh). Sharh Hal va Araye Falsafi Molla Sadra (4th ed). Qum: Daftar Tablighat Islami.
28.Ayati, M. I. (1992/1371Sh). Maghuolat va Arae Marbut bi An. Tehran: Tehran university.
29.Ibn Marzban, B. (1996/1375Sh). Al-Tahsil (2th ed). Edited by Mortaza Motahari. Tehran: Tehran university. 30.Hoseyni Ardakani, A. (1996/1375Sh). Merat Al-Akvaan. Edited by Abd al-Allah Nuorani. Tehran: Daftar Nashr Mirath al-Maktoob.
31.Ibn Rushd, M. (1947/1366Ah). Rasaeil Ibn Rushd. Heydar Abad: Daerat al-Maaref al-Osmaniya.
32.Ibn Sina. (/19851364). Al-Nijat (2th ed). Tehran: Mortazaviya publication.
33. Ibn Sina. )19871366. Sh( Al-Hodood (2th ed). Tehran: Soroush Publication.
34. Ibn Sina. )19871366 Ah( Al-Isharat va Al-Tanbihat (2th ed). Maktab Nashr al-Kotob.
35. Ibn Sina. (1984/1405Ah). Al-Shifa. Qum: Ayato Allah Marashi publication.
36.Kaplsvn, F. (1983/1362Sh). History of Philosophy. Translated by Jalal al-din Mojtabavi. Tehran: Elmi Farhangi Book Store.
37.Khaminey, M. (2005/1384Sh). Mirdamad. Tehran: Sadra Islamic Philosophy Research Institute.
38.Motahri, M. (1983/1363Sh). Harakat va Zaman Dar Falsafe Islami. Tehran: Hikmat publication.
39.Motahri, M. (1994/1373Sh). Maghalat Falsafi. Tehran: Sadra publication.
40.Ramin, F. (2001/1380Sh). Mabani Falsafi Sadr Al-Motaalehin. Tehran: Sadra Islamic Philosophy Research Institute 41.Rezanajad (Nooshin), Gh. (2001/1380Sh). Hikmat Name. Tehran: Al-Zahra publication.
42.Sharif, M. M. (1986/1365Sh). History of Philosophy in Islam. Translated by Nasr Allah pur Javadi. Tehran: University Publication Center.
The Journal of Research in Humanities
Volume 23, Issue 1
January 2017
Pages 53-70