Comparative Study of Political Thought of Rashid Rida and Ali Abdel Raziq

Authors
A. Qaderi 1
ُ. H. Aghajari 2
M. goljan 2
1 university of tarbiat modares
2 University of Tarbiyat modares
Abstract
Political thought of Muslim in the middle of abolition of the Ottoman Caliphate, as a symbol of Islamic world, followed with two reactions. A group, under Rashid Rida as thinker of the group, was thinking of caliphate to its real origin. The other group, under Ali Abdel Raziq, was come to being with his prominent book entitled “Islam and Foundations of Governance”, thinking that caliphate is historic and considered it as a worn-out and dilapidated system. The attitude of these groups was tantamount to showing reaction to the critical environment of the Islamic community with transient state. The origin of this conflict returns to the issue of relationship between reasons and religion in modern era. Moreover, position of the duo in the though of Muslims is the other main basis of this conflict. Responding to this issue can be observed in considering “reason” along with religion as practiced by Rashid Rida and also considering it as an independent source in religion belonged to Abdel Raziq.

Keywords

Subjects

.38.Adams, C.
Charles (1933). Islam And Modernism in Egypt: A study of the Modern Movement Inaugurated By Muhammad Abduh. The American University at Cairo oriental studies, first Published
. References
1.Abdorrazzaq, A. (Dhu'l-Qa'dah ( ١٣۴٩)
. Hezaratona al-qadimah fera'niyat a'm A'rabiyah a'm gharbiyah? al-helal, Volume 93, Issue 6, 817-827.
2. Abdorrazzaq, A. (Dhu'l-Qa'dah. (1925). Al-islam va usolol al-hokm bahth fi al-khelafah va al-hokomah fi al-islam (Islam and Foundations of Governance), dar al-helal.
3.Adams, C. Charles (1933). Islam And Modernism in Egypt: A study of the Modern Movement Inaugurated By Muhammad Abduh. The American University at Cairo oriental studies, first Published.
4.Al-khelafah and Mastery Ommah (1995). Translation from Turkish Abdolghani Sani Bak, Intiduction Dr. Nasr Hamed Abozied, Cairo, Published by Dar al-nahr.
5.Amin, A. (Rabi' al-thani 1354 AH). Noaie Faqid al-islam va al-moslemin al-imam Mohammad Rashid Reda, Al-manar, Vol 35, pp 153-162.
6.A'mmarah, M. (2006). Min Aa'lam al-ehuaa al-islami, Cairo, Maktabat al-shoroq al-dawliyah.
7.A'sem, A. (rajab 1358). Al-syyed Muhammad rashid reda, al-manar, Vol 35, pp 480-504.
8.Farasatkhah, M. (1374). The beginning new thought temporary (Religion and non- religion), Sherkat sahami inteshar. 9.Gospel of Matthew, Render unto Caeser (22).
10.Lapidus, I. M. (1387). A History of Islamic societies. tr by Ali Bakhtiyarizadeh. Tehran: published by ettelaa'at. Downloaded from aijh.modares.ac.ir at 8:32 IRST on Saturday January 11th 2020
11.Qazi zadeh, K. (1375). Based on legitimacy valayat Ma'somin. Hokumat islami, vol 1, pp 96-135.
12.Reda, M. R. (Muḥarram 1320 AH). Al-qazaa' fi al-islam(2), al- manar, vol 5, pp 11-18.
13. Reda, M. R.. (Rabi' al-awwal 1320 AH). Al-qazaa' fi al-islam (4), al- manar, vol 5, pp 161-175.
14. Reda, M. R.. (safar 1325 AH). Sonan al-ijtemaa' fi al-hakemin va al-mahkomin lahom va jazao'hom, al- manar, vol 10, pp 107-111.
15. Reda, M. R.. (Sha'ban 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (5), al- manar, vol 24, pp 257-273.
16 Reda, M. R... (Sha'ban 1341 AH). Monazeraton fi al-jamea't al-mesriyah fi al-madanietain al-fera'niya va al-a'rabiyah (va ayatahoma takhtaro mesr haza al-a'sr!?). al- manar, vol 31, pp 465-474.
17. Reda, M. R.. (Shawwāl 1335 AH). Al-masalat al-A'rabiyeh. al- manar, vol 20, pp 33-48.
18. Reda, M. R.. (Shawwāl 1335 AH). Mo'tamer al-khelafah. al- manar, vol 25, pp 525-535.
19 Reda, M. R... Al-Khilafa aw al-Imama al-Uzma [The caliphate or the great imamate].
20 Reda, M. R... (10 Sha'ban 1316 AH). Al-islah al-dini al-moqtareh a'la maqam al-khelafah al-islamiyeh, al- manar, vol 1, pp 778- 794.
21. Reda, M. R.. (10 Sha'ban 1327 AH). Al-dastor va al-horiyyat va al-din al-islami, al- manar, vol 12, pp 606-612.
22. Reda, M. R.. (12 Rabi' al-thani 1317 AH). Al-din va al-dolah av al-khelafah va al-saltanah, al- manar, vol 2, pp 353- 360.
23. Reda, M. R., (16 Jamadi al-thani 1316 AH). Al-khelafah va al-kholafaa (1), al- manar, vol 1, pp 628-633.
24. Reda, M. R.. (23 Jamadi al-thani 1316 AH). Al-khelafah va al-kholafaa (2), al- manar, vol 1, pp 649-655.
25 Reda, M. R... (3 Sha'ban 1316 AH). Al-islah al-dini al-moqtareh a'la maqam al-khelafah al-islamiyeh, al- manar, vol 1, pp 764- 771.
26. Reda, M. R.. (Dhu'l-Qa'dah 1326 AH). Al-khotbah al-thaniyeh min khotabina fi al-diyar al-soriyeh va hiya min al-khotab al-siyasiyeh. al- manar, vol 11, pp 836-842.
27 Reda, M. R... (Jumada al-Oola 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (2). al- manar, vol 24, pp 33-67.
28. Reda, M. R.. (Jumada al-thani 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (3). al- manar, vol 24, pp 98-121.
29. Reda, M. R.. (Rabi' al-awwal 1342 AH). Loghat al-islam va al-loghat al-rasmiyeh bayn al-mamalik al-islamiyeh. al- manar, vol 24, pp 753-766.
30. Reda, M. R.. (Rabi' al-thani 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (1). al- manar, vol 23, pp 729-753.
31. Reda, M. R.. (Rabi' al-thani 1354 AH). Al-reba va al-zakat va al-zarayeb va dar al-harb. al- manar, vol 35, pp 131-134.
32 Reda, M. R... (Rabi' al-thani 1354 AH). Soalan a'n al-reba fi dar al-harb, a'n kone al-islam dinon siyasiyah a'm la. al- manar, vol 35, pp 127-131.
33 Reda, M. R... (Rajab 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (4). al- manar, vol 24, pp 185-201.
34. Reda, M. R.. (Ramazan 1325 AH). Bahth fi al-mo'tamar al-islami le-taa'rof al-moslemin va al-bahth a'n asbab za'fihim va tariqo a'lajihi va tarikho al-da'va iliehi. al- manar, vol 10, pp 673-683.
35 Reda, M. R... (Ramazan 1341 AH). Al-ahkam al-shara'Iyah al-motaa'leqah bel-khelafah al-islamiyeh (6). al- manar, vol 24, pp 345-373.
36 Reda, M. R... (Ramazan 1342 AH). Al-khlelafah va al-khalifa al-imam al-haq fi hazihi al-ayyam. al- manar, vol 25, pp 257-273.
37. Reda, M. R.. (Ramazan 1343 AH). Fatawa al-manar. al- manar, vol 26, pp 28-33.
38. Reda, M. R. . (Ramazan 1346 AH). Moqademeh ketab yosr al-islam va osulo al-tashria' al-a'am. al- manar, vol 29, pp 63-71
The Journal of Research in Humanities
Volume 23, Issue 1
January 2017
Pages 35-52