Evaluation of defenses of Attributed lying to the Prophets (pbuh) in the Qur'an

Author
ک. روحی برندق
Associate Professor- tarbiyat modares university
Abstract
Lying doubt is the most serious doubts about the divine prophets that has long been fueled by resorting to the conspicuity of some verses and traditions. In this paper after specifing concepts of Lying and Dissimulation in terminology and technical expression, analysis four doubt of lying related to Prophet Ibrahim and a doubt of lying Prophet Yusuf (pbuh) and assessed the solutions proposed. In response to the question of lie mixed with Shrek and the Sabian’s Prophet Ibrahim, we accepted promotion of monotheistic position of Abraham’s solution, and in the case of malingering false; he perceives diagnosis disease or its tim by looking at the stars and this solution adjusts with the apparent of verses. And lying about breaking the large idols, is justified by white lie by virtue of dissimulation. And named his wife Sarah as his sister, all traditions are fictional. And in case of doubt or approval lies by prophet Yusuf (pbuh), white lie is a solution and also it was justified by the permission of Allah. Other solutions about all every five doubts are unjustified.

Keywords

Subjects

1.TheHoly Qur’an.
2.Ibn Gozi, Abd-al-Rahman bin Ali, (1412); Al-Montazam fi Tarikh al-Omam and al-Molok, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
3.Ibn Sa’ad, Mohammad bin Sa’ad, (Undated); Al-Tabaghat al-Kobra, Beirut: Sader Publicacions.
4.Ibn Arabi, mohi al-Din, (1422); Tafsir Ibn Arabi, Mostafa Robab, Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage. 5.Ibn Fares, Ahmad, (1979); Mo’ajam Maghaeeis al-Loghat, Abd-al-Salam Mohammad Haroon, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
6.Ibn Ghodame, Ibn Ahmad Abdollah Al-maghdasi, (1405); Al-Moghni fi Feghh al-Emam Ahmad bin Hanbal al-Shaybani, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
7.Ibn Kasir, Esma’ail bin Omar, (1419); AL-tafsir al-Quran al-Aziem, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
8.Ibn Kamone, Sa’ad bin Mansor, (1402); Al-Jadid fi al-hekmat, Baghdad: Baghdad University.
9.Ibn Manzour, Mohammad bin Mokarram (Undated); Arab language. Beirut: Sader Publicacions. 10.Abu So’aoud, Mohammad bin Mohammad (Undated); Tafsir Abi al-So’aoud, Ershad al-Aghl al-Salim ela Mazaya al-Quran al-Karim, Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage.
11.Abu Hayyan, Mohammad bin Yosof, (1420); Al-bahr al-Moheit fi al-Tafsir, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
12.Isfahani, Mohammad Hossine, (1418); Hashiat al-Makaseb, Research of al-shaykh Abbas Mohammad al sabba’a al-Ghatifi,(Unspaced); Scientific.
13.Amin, Mohsen, (1403); A’ayan al-Shi’at, Beirut: Ta’arof Publicacions.
14.Ansari, Shaykh Morteza, (1415); Al-Makaseh al-Moharemat, Qom: Seminar World Shaykh A’azam Ansari.
15.Alosy, Mohmoud bin Abdollah, (1415); Rooh al-ma’any fi Tafsir al-Quran al-Aziem, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
16.Amoli, Haydar bin Ali, (1428); Tafsir al-Moheit al-Azam and al-Bahr al-Khazem fi Tawil Khetab Allah al-Aziz al-Mohkam, Al-Sayyed Mohsen al-Mousavi al-Tabrizi, Qom: Noor ala Noor.
17.Bokhari, Mohammad bin Esma’aeil, (Undated); Saheih al-Bokhari, Istanbol: Islami Publicacions.
18. Baghavi, Khaled Abd al-Rahman al-A’ak, (Undated); Ma’aalem al-Tanzil fi Tafsir al-Quran(Tafsir al- Baghavi), Beirut: Encyclopedia.
19.Balaghi, Mohammad Javad, (1405); Al-hoda Ela Din al-Mostafa, Beirut: Al-A’alami Institute. 20.Bayzawi, Abdollah bin Omar, (1418); Anwar al-Tanzil and Asrar al-Tawil (Tafsir Beyzawi), Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage.
21.Tabrizi, Abotaleb Taglil, (1421); Al-T’alighat al-Istedlaliat Ala Tahrir al-Wasilat, Tehran: Imam Khomayni Publication Traces Institute.
22.Tabrizi, Razi bin Mohammad Hossine Nagafi, (1413); Tahlil al-Kalam fi Feghh al-Islam, Tehran: Amire Ghalam.
23.Tabrizi, Mirza Fattah Shahidi, (1375); Hedayat al-Taleb Ela Asrar al-Makaseb, Tabriz: Press Information.
24.Taftazani, Masoud bin Omar, (Undated); Al-motawwal and Bahamasheh Hashiat Al-Sayyed Mir Sharif, Qom: Al-Dawari Publicacion.
25.Sa’aalebi, Abu Zayd Abd al-Rahman bin Mohammad bin Makhlof, (1418); Al-Gawaher al-Hesan fiTafsir al-Quran, Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage.
26.Jassas, Ahmad bin Ali, (1405); Ahkam al-Quran, Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage.
27.Hashemi Shahrodi, Mohmoud, (1426); Farhang Feghh Motabegh Mazhab Ahl Bayt, Qom: Islamic Fiqh Encyclopedia Institute on Religion Ahl al-Bayt (AS).
28.Hashemi Shahrodi, Mohmoud, (1417);Mo’ajam Feghh al-Gawaher, Beirut: Alghadir Publicacion. 29.Hashemi Shahrodi, Mohmoud, (1423); Moso’at al-Feghh Islami, Motabegh Mazhab Ahl Bayt, Qom: Islamic Fiqh Encyclopedia Institute on Religion Ahl al-Bayt (AS).
30.Johari, Ismaeil bin Hammad, (1376); Al-Sehah Tag al-Loghat and Sehah al-Arabiat, Beirut: Millennium Scientific Publicacions.
31.Howayzi, Abd Ali bin Jom’ah, Tafsir Noor Alsaghalain, Qom: Isma’aylian.
32.Khomayni, Rohollah, (1415); Al-Makaseb al-Moharamat, Qom: Imam Khomayni Traces Publicion Institute.
33.Khoi, Abolghasem, (Undated); Mesbah al-feghahat, Qom: Al-Dawari Publicacion.
34.Ansari Dezfoli, Morteza bin Mohammad Amin, (1411); Al-Makaseb, Qom: Manshorat al-zakhaer Publicacions.
35.Razi, Fakhr al-Din Mohammad bin Omar, (1421); Mafatih al-Ghayb, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
36.Razi, Fakhr al-Din Mohammad bin Omar, (1988); Esmat al-Anbya, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
37.Ragheb Isfahani, Hossine bin Mohammad, (Undated); Al-Mofradat fi Gharib al-Quran, Beirut: Ghalam Publicacions.
38.Zobaydi, Morteza Mohammad bin Mohammad, (1414); Tag al-Arous men Gawaher al-Ghamous, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
39.Zarkeshi, Mohammad bin Bahador bin Abdollah, (1410); Al-Borhan fi Olum al-Quran, Beirut: Almarefat Publicacions.
40.Zemakhshari, Mohamoud bin Omar, (1417); Alfayegh, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions. 41.Zemakhshari, Mohamoud bin Omar, (1407); Alkhashaf an Haghaygh Ghawamez al-Tanzil andOyoun al-Aghawil fi Wogoh al-Tawil, Beirut: Al-Arabi Book Publicacions.
42.Sobhani, Jafar, (1424); Al-Mawaheb fi Tahrir Ahkam al-Makaseb, Qom: Imam Sadegh Institute.
43. Sabzewari, Abd al-A’ala, (1413); Mohazzab al-Ahkam, Qom: Al-menar Institute.
44.Madani Shirazi, Sayyed Ali Khan, (1384); Al-Taraz al-Awwal and al-Konaz Lema alayh menLoghat al-Arab al-Mo’awal, Mashhad: Al al-Bayt Revival Heritage Institute.
45.Alam al-Hoda, Ali bin Hossein, (1405);Rasayel al-Sharif al-morteza, Qom: Holy Qur’an Publicacions. 46.Alam al-Hoda, Ali bin Hossein, (Undated); Tanzyat al-Anbya, Qom: al-Sharif al-morteza Publicacions.
47.Souti, Jalal al-Din Abd al-Rahman bin Abibakr, (1996); Al-dibaj ala Moslem, Al-mamlekat al-s’audiat: Ibn Afan Publicacions.
48.Shobbar, Abdollah, (1407); Al-Johar Al-Samin fi Tafsir al-Ketab al-Mobin, Koweit: Al-Fin Publicacion
49.Shanghiti, Mohammad bin Mohammad al-Mokhtar, (1415); Azwa al-Bayan fi Iyzah al-Quran bel-Quran, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
50.Saheb bin Abad, Esma’ail (1414); Al-Moheit fi al-Loghat, Beirut: Alam Book Publicacion.
51.Sadr, Mohammad,(1420); Mawara al-Feghh, Beirut: Al-azwa Publicacion.
52.Tabatabai, Mohammad Hossein, (1393); Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Quran, Beirut: Al-A’alami Institute. 53.Tabarsi, Ahmad bin Ali (1361); Al-Ehtegag ala Ahle al-Legag, Mashhad: Al-morteza Publicacion. 54.Tabarsi, Fazl bin Hasan (1372); Mjma’a al-byan fi Tafsir al-Quran, Tehran: Naser Khosrow. 55.Torayhi, Fakhr al-Din bin Mohammad, (1375); Mjma’a al-bahrayn, Tehran: Mortazawi.
56.Tayyeb, Abd al-Hossine, (1378); Atyab al-byan fi Tafsir al-Quran, Tehran: Islam.
57.Askari, Hasan bin Abdollah, (1980); Alforough fi al-Loghat, Beirut: Alafagh al-Jadidah Publicacion. 58.Farahidi, Khalil, (Undated); Al’ayn, Qom: Hegrat.
59.Firoz Abadi, Mohammad bin Yaghob, (1415); Al-ghamos al-Moheit, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
60.Fayumi, Ahmad bin Mohammad, (1414); Al-Mesbah al-Monir fi Gharib al-Sharh al-Kabir lelrafe’ai, Qom: Al-Hegrat Institute.
61.Ghasemi, Mohammad Jamal al-Din, (1418); Mahasen al-Tawil, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions. 62.Ghortabi, Mohammad bin Mohammad, (1364); Al-Jame’a Le-ahkam al-Quran, Tehran: Naser Khosrow.
63.Kolayni, Mohammad bin Yaghob, (1407); Al-kafi, Tehran: ISlamic Books Publicacions.
64.Mahmoud Abd al-Rahman, (Undated); Mojam al-Mostalahat and al-Alfaz al-Feghiyat.
65.Maraghi, Ahmad Mostafa, (Undated); Tafsir al-Maraghi, Beirut: Thought Publicacions.
66.Mesbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taghi, (1386); Ma’aref Quran (4 and 5) Rah and Rahnama Shenasi, Qom: Imam Khomayni Education and Investigation Institute.
67.Mostafawi, Hasan, (Undated); Al-Tahghigh fi Kalemat al-Quran, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
68.Mozaffar, Mohammad Reza, (1430); Al-Mantegh, Qom: ISlamic Publicacions Institute of Jama’at al-Modaresin.
69.Moghnieh, Mohammad Jawad, (1424); Al-Tafsir al-kashef, Qom: ISlamic Book Publicacions Institute.
70.Maghrizi, Ahmad bin Ali. (1420); Emta’a al-Asma’a bema lel-nabi men al-Ahwal and al-amwal and al-Hafedah and al-Mata’a, Beirut: Scientific Books Publicacions.
71.Makarem Shirazi, Naser (1386); Payam Quran, Tehran: ISlamic Books Publicacions.
72.Mousavi, Hossein Yusof, (1410); Al-Ifsah fi feghh al-Loghat, Qom: Al-Aa’lam ISlamic Publicacions. 73.Najafi, Mohammad Hasan bin Bagher, (1362); Jawaher al-Kalam fi Sharh Shara’a al-Islam, Beirut: Revival of Arabic Heritage.
74.Nahhas, Abi Jafar, (1409); Ma’ani al-Quran al-Karim, Al-mamlekat al-s’audiat: Jame’at Om al-Ghora.
75.Nasaei, Abi Abd-al-Rahman Ahmad bin Sho’aib, (Undated); Fazael al-Sahabat, Beirut: ISlamic Books Publicacions.
The Journal of Research in Humanities
Volume 22, Issue 2
March 2016
Pages 17-32